Situational Paper |
The first formal summit meeting of the heads of the member states of the 16-member Conference on Interaction and Confidence Building Measures in Asia (CICA) was held in Almaty (Kazakhstan), on 3-5 June, 2002. The Almaty moot had earlier been scheduled to take place in November 2001, in Almaty, but was postponed due to the September 11 incident. The member states of the conference include; Azerbaijan, Afghanistan, Egypt, India, Iran, Israel, Kazakhstan, China, Kyrgyzstan, Mongolia, Palestine, Pakistan, Russia, Tajikistan, Turkey, and Uzbekistan. The main purpose of the meeting was to sign the "Almaty Act" and "Declaration on Eliminating Terrorism and Promoting Dialogues among Civilizations" by the heads of the member states. These documents elaborate the main purpose of the Conference, i.e., to work towards mutual confidence building and conflict prevention in Asia, thereby ensuring stability and peace in the Asian continent. (Annex) The idea for the formation of CICA was floated by Kazakh President, Nursultan Nazarbayev in 1992, when he came up with the initiative to create a new international organization in Asia on the patterns of OSCE. Realizing the importance of the proposal, several meetings of the experts from various Asian countries were held in 1993-94. The meetings resulted in establishment of a Special Working Group (SWG), aimed at the preparation of a conference of the foreign ministers of the interested states. The first meeting of SWG was held in 1995. The Kazakh Foreign Ministry also held two meetings of the Deputy Foreign Ministers of the interested states, in which representatives of 23 Asian countries agreed that the development of the CICA needed a long term and common effort of all participants. The international colloquium "Asian Security in the Context of Convening the CICA", held in Almaty in October 1998, was an important step in this regard. The heads and members of the leading scientific and research centres from Asia, Europe, and the US took part in the colloquium to exchange views on all aspects of Asian security, with emphasis on pursuing the idea of creating a regional security system in the form of CICA. The meeting of Foreign Ministers of the member states, held in Almaty on September 14, 1998, became the biggest achievement for Kazakhstan. It was here for the first time, that a legal basis of an Asian security system, providing for concrete activities, measures, and mechanisms of ensuring stability in the region, was created. The meeting also paved the way for signing the "Declaration of Principles", forming this organization. The Declaration laid down the following main principles of the Conference: Main Principles of CICA
Later on, several meetings of the SWG were held in the subsequent years to finalize the draft of CICA Summit Document, to be signed by the heads of the member states. The June 2002 summit was held to sign the documents and formally initiate the working of "Conference on Interaction and Confidence Building Measures in Asia". The "Almaty Act" aimed at the security cooperation and confidence building among the CICA member states against security threats to Asia. While "The Declaration" emphasizes the denunciation of terrorist acts, measures against the fundamental cause of terrorism, and key role to be played by the UN in the coalition against terrorism. Besides the signing of the document, the conference's main focus remained on the resolution of tension between two nuclear rivals - India and Pakistan - who have been at the brink of a nuclear war over the Kashmir issue. Efforts to Resolve India-Pakistan Tension It was after 36 years since the signing of the "Tashkent Declaration" in 1966 that the Russian Federation decided to actively involve itself in the context of India-Pakistan tension. The Russian President, Vladimir Putin, tried to play the role of peacemaker to mediate between India and Pakistan, and to avoid escalation in their conflict. Mr. Putin in his opening remarks to the summit said, "the explosive state of relation between India and Pakistan causes deep concern seriously destabilising the situation on the entire South Asian subcontinent." Following his meeting with Pakistan's President, General Pervez Musharraf, Vladimir Putin told the Indian Prime Minister, Atal Bihari Vajpayee, that Pakistan President Musharraf had offered some positive proposals to resolve tensions with India. However, no details of the proposals were revealed. He, however, could not succeed in bringing both the South Asian rivals on the negotiation table because of India's constant refusal to talk to Pakistan. Nevertheless, Putin invited both India and Pakistan to come to Moscow to discuss and resolve their major disputes and conflicts, particularly that of Kashmir. Pakistan's President Musharraf has accepted the invitation, but the Indian side has rejected the proposal of holding peace talks in Moscow. Despite his unsuccessful diplomatic venture, Putin said that he was hopeful of a peaceful resolution of conflict between India and Pakistan, as both sides had pledged "to the principle of resolving the conflict without using force." It is widely believed that a meeting between the two leaders of India and Pakistan at this tense moment could have paved the way for further talks, thereby leading to a military de-escalation, and perhaps an end to the current standoff. However, hopes that such a meeting would take place were dashed due to Indians' constant refusal to hold any dialogue with Pakistan, unless and until "cross-border incursion" into the Indian occupied Kashmir by the "militants" supported by Pakistan halted. Pakistan, however, showed extreme willingness for "unconditional talks" with India to resolve all issues of concern, including the core issue of Kashmir. For Pakistan, the Almaty Declaration once again proves its contention that the international community - including India - has to fulfill its obligations regarding Kashmir in accordance with the UN Resolutions and international law. While self-determination may have become unfashionable, it is a legitimate goal under international law and contrary to what Kofi Annan may claim, in his realpolitik game plan, UN resolutions and international law are not time barred or outdated. Almaty has clearly shown that. Also, unlike the notion of terrorism, self-determination has been clearly identified within international law and it still remains a peremptory norm of international law (jus cogens). This norm (of self-determination) is not only a part of customary international law, but is also enshrined as one of the principles of the UN as laid out in Article 1:2 of its Charter. The United Nations sees self-determination within the context of people fighting against colonialism, foreign occupation and to enforce international commitments made to them. The strength of the self-determination norm is such that international conventions dealing with terrorism have always acknowledged and distinguished between struggles for self-determination and acts of terrorism and the Almaty Declaration is no exception. Critical Appreciation The CICA is the first security organization, which covers the entire Asian region, unlike the Shanghai Cooperation Organization, which deals with a specific part the Asian continent. The geo-political and economic scope of the CICA is quite large compared to other regions of the world. The overall territory of the 16 members countries constitutes 388 million square kilometres, which is about 89 % of the whole of Asia, and 72% of Eurasia. It is home to almost 3 billion people, which is 50% of the world's population. Among the member states, Russia, China, India, and Pakistan are nuclear weapon states. The member states attract a considerable share of world's volumes of investment owing to their hydrocarbon reserves, particularly oil and gas, and other economic potentials. The total hydrocarbon reserves and production of CICA members, like Russia, Iran, Kazakhstan, and Azerbaijan, represents a significant portion of the world's resource base and production. But to utilize this economic potential to its full extent, political stability and maintenance of peace is a prerequisite. So, to provide a platform to the Asian states to enhance mutual cooperation, and to maintain and ensure peace and stability in the Asian continent was a good initiative by the Kazakh President, Nursultan Nazarbayev. Most of the member states have bilateral territorial and border disputes with each other. For example, Pakistan-India dispute, Israel-Palestine dispute etc. The forum could play a major role in easing persistent tensions arising out of such disputes, and also provide a set of principles to resolve them by employing amicable means of settlement. Although, the CICA efforts to resolve disputes may not bring fruits in the near future, but the constant process of dialogue and active involvement of the member states can pave the way for lasting peace and stability in this "conflict-ridden region" in the long run. On the Asian continent, the countries of West Asia, East Asia, and Far East hold importance due to their economic development and opportunities they hold for the other regional and international countries. Since many among them are not members of the Conference, such as Saudi Arabia, Indonesia, Malaysia etc, extending membership to them will not only strengthen, but will also add to the importance of the Conference. Particularly for the Muslim states of West Asia, the importance of membership of the CICA cannot be denied, since Israel being a member can exploit this opportunity to project its own stance on Palestinian issue, therefore negatively effecting Palestinians' struggle for liberation against the yoke of Israeli occupation. Also, the documents signed at the Conference are a manifestation of its resolve to work towards maintaining peace in the Asian region, plagued with non-traditional sources of social instability and conflict, such as terrorism, religious militancy, drug trafficking, nuclear proliferation, smuggling of small arms, migration etc. Both the documents have addressed almost all these major issues, but they are not free from loopholes. For instance, the Almaty Act while condemns "separatist movements", also recognizes the "right of self-determination" for people living under foreign occupation. Moreover, it condemns religious extremism, but does not raise the issue of massacre unleashed against religious minorities in certain member states. A major example of this is Indian callousness against Muslim and Christian minorities in India. It also does not mention the issue of "state terrorism", witnessed in Kashmir and Palestine where innocent civilians are subjected to the Indian and Israeli troops' atrocities on a daily basis. However, despite all those drawbacks, the Conference could be helpful in providing many good venues and opportunities to the member states. It is for the first time that the Central Asian region hosted an international conference on such a large scale, which is the manifestation of their emerging status and position in the international community. The Conference gave confidence to the Central Asian States, which have lesser diplomatic experience. Since Russia took the initiative in helping de-escalate Pak-India tension, it signifies Russia's interests in the region coupled with Russia's desire of playing a major role in the region and world affairs. It also reflects Russia's concerns regarding a major instability in the neighbourhood that may have serious ramifications for it as well. The Conference provided Pakistan with a renewed opportunity to forge friendly relations with Russia, earlier missed by the successive Pakistani governments. On the sidelines of the Conference, President, General Pervez Musharraf paid a visit to Tajikistan, which is economically and strategically an important state for Pakistan because of its economic potentials and opportunities that it can provide to Pakistan. Pakistan already has friendly relations with almost all the Central Asian States, and has signed several agreements for enhancing economic cooperation. A recent example is the Pakistan-Turkmenistan-Afghanistan gas pipeline deal, which the heads of the three states signed in May 2002, to construct a gas pipeline from the Dulatabad gas fields in Turkmenistan via Afghanistan to the Gawader port of Pakistan. This pipeline project, if materialised, will bring economic prosperity to all the three participants of the project. The CICA can provide Asia with the enduring and lasting peace if the documents and drafts signed in the course of the Almaty meeting are implemented in letter and spirit, and the member states show their commitment to work towards ensuring peace in this region. Sadia Sulaiman ALMATY DECLARATION Preamble We, the Heads of State or Government of the Member States of the Conference on Interaction and Confidence Building Measures in Asia (CICA), Having met in Almaty at a time of profound changes which are taking place in Asia and the world to set up our vision of security in Asia and enhance our capabilities for co-operation on issues of common concern for our peoples; Recognising the close link between peace, security and stability in Asia and in the rest of the world; Committing ourselves to working to ensure peace and security in Asia and making it a region open to dialogue and co-operation; Believing that the CICA process presents new opportunities for co-operation, peace and security in Asia; Declaring our determination to form in Asia a common and indivisible area of security, where all states peacefully co-exist, and their peoples live in conditions of peace, freedom and prosperity, and confident that peace, security and development complement, sustain and reinforce each other; Reaffirming our commitment to the UN Charter, as well as to the Declaration on the Principles Guiding Relations Among CICA Member States, which is an integral part of the Almaty Act, as the basis for our future co-operation; Considering that all aspects of comprehensive security in Asia, including its political and military aspects, confidence-building measures, economic and environmental issues, humanitarian and cultural co-operation, are interdependent and interrelated and should be pursued actively; Confident that full, equal and comprehensive implementation and observance of the principles, provisions and commitments enshrined in the Almaty Act will create the conditions for advanced co-operation among the CICA Member States and will guide us towards a better future, which our peoples deserve; Have adopted the following: I. Security and co-operation.
II. Challenges to security.
III. Confidence Building Measures
IV. Structure and institutions of CICA
1. Regular meetings
2. Specialised meetings
3. Academic and professional inputs
4. Secretariat
II) DECLARATION ON ELIMINATING TERRORISM AND PROMOTING DIALOGUE AMONG CIVILIZATIONS We, the Heads of State or Government of the Member States of the Conference on Interaction and Confidence Building Measures in Asia (CICA), gathered in Almaty for the First CICA Summit, do hereby declare the following: We are deeply concerned by the increase in all acts of terrorism worldwide, including in CICA Member States. We are fully committed to fighting terrorism and strengthening bilateral, regional and international cooperation, in accordance with the UN Charter, required to meet this challenge. We emphasize the central role of the United Nations, its General Assembly and Security Council, in developing the framework for this. We express our deepest sorrow over the loss of innocent lives in all acts, methods or practices of terrorism and convey our sympathies and condolences to the families of the victims. We condemn all forms and manifestations of terrorism, committed no matter when, where or by whom, as barbaric offences and criminal acts indiscriminately directed at the life and well-being of innocent individuals and peoples as well as threatening the peaceful coexistence among nations. No considerations whatsoever can be invoked to justify terrorism. We are convinced that terrorism constitutes a direct violation of human rights and, in particular, the right to life, freedom, security and development. We emphasize that eliminating terrorism is the common goal of all cultures and civilizations. We believe that all religions of the world reject violence and terrorism and advocate the protection of human rights. We underline that terrorism cannot be attributed to religion, nationality, or civilization. We believe that it is essential not to allow terrorists to lure us into a conflict of religions, cultures or civilizations. We also pledge to be particularly vigilant, in order to ensure that the global fight against terrorism does not become a war targeting particular cultures, religions or nations. We all stand united in this fight. We reaffirm our strong commitment to all norms and principles of international law, the purposes and principles of the UN Charter, including the right to self-determination, and the CICA Almaty Act concerning the maintenance of international peace and security and the promotion of good-neighbourly and friendly relations and cooperation among countries. We actively support efforts undertaken by the international community, in accordance with UN Charter, to combat terrorism. The fight against terrorism should be global, comprehensive and sustained, and not selective or discriminatory and should avoid applying double standards. We are also against using the fight against terrorism as a pretext for interference in the internal affairs of sovereign States. We reject the use of force not in compliance with the UN Charter against sovereign States. We reaffirm the key significance of, and pledge to fully support implementation of, UN Security Council Resolution No. 1373 and other relevant UN resolutions on combating terrorism which provide the basic framework for national, regional and international obligations and efforts to combat this universal evil. We underscore the need to respect human rights and rule of law in combating terrorism. We encourage States Parties to the various UN anti-terrorism Conventions to consult and cooperate, in accordance with the provisions of these Conventions, to ensure their effective implementation. We will contribute to the early elaboration and adoption by the UN of other appropriate instruments, such as the Comprehensive Convention on International Terrorism and the International Convention for the Suppression of Acts of Nuclear Terrorism. We are open for cooperation in combating terrorism with all other states, regional and international organizations and forums. Taking into account the trans-national character of terrorism, as well as its close links with other challenges and threats to security such as organized crime, narcotics and human trafficking as well as illicit arms trafficking, we will seek to foster cooperation between our relevant authorities and to maintain regular exchange of information in order to enhance international capacity to stop financing of terrorism and eliminate it. We consider as one of the primary tasks of the international community to strengthen efforts to eliminate poverty, unemployment, illiteracy, extremism, intolerance, entrenched hatred and all forms of discrimination. We believe that it is necessary to ensure sustainable development of all regions of the world and to pay more attention to the socio-economic impact of globalization. It will also be of high importance for our cause to encourage the peaceful settlement of regional and international crises and conflicts. We support international efforts for the rehabilitation and reconstruction of Afghanistan in order to help revive this country as a stable and prosperous member of the international community. The CICA Member States intend to strengthen cooperation and dialogue among them in order to promote common values, mutual understanding and confidence for the benefit of the joint fight against terrorism. We consider CICA as a unique Asian forum which comprises states of different cultures and traditions making it one of the most important mechanisms to promote dialogue among civilizations and cultures. In this context, we reconfirm our full support for the United Nations General Assembly Resolution A/RES/56/6 on Dialogue among Civilizations and are convinced that implementation of its Programme of Action positively contributes to international efforts to attain universal peace, welfare and stability. The CICA Member States intend to comprehensively and actively promote such a dialogue taking into account that Eurasia has not only been a cradle of some of the world's largest civilizations but has also served as a bridge between them. |